Vidéo – But spectaculaire de Boufal face à Yassine Bounou    Casablanca : La réouverture du Complexe Sportif Mohammed V annoncée pour fin mai    Examen des moyens de coopération agricole entre le Maroc et la RDC    Le ministère de la Santé organise la Semaine nationale de vaccination    L'artiste-peintre Abdellah El Haitout expose à Tanger    Les Instances représentatives des communautés israélites marocaines réanimées    ONCF: 2 millions de voyageurs durant les dernières vacances scolaires    SIGPA souligne l'importance de l'agriculture au sein de sa stratégie commerciale    Réouverture du Complexe Sportif Mohammed V    Siam 2019 : Soufiane Alaoui, DG de Soulara    Parlement: Le PAM remplace son chef de groupe    Loi-cadre sur l'enseignement: La CDT prépare ses conseillers    Agriculture durable: CAM s'aligne sur les objectifs de la FAO    Constitution: Référendum en Egypte    Langues = avenir    Cinéma: «Les 3M, une histoire inachevée» Une ode à l'amitié au-delà de la religion    CAN 2019. 56 arbitres en stage de préparation à partir du 28 avril à Rabat    Le roi Mohammed VI donne ses instructions au ministre de l'Intérieur    Rabat hausse le ton : Le Maroc rejette certaines idées et projets improductifs véhiculés au sujet de la question du Sahara    Partenariat en faveur de l'écosystème de la cédraie du Moyen Atlas    L'expertise suisse au service des montagnes marocaines    S.M le Roi offre un dîner en l'honneur des invités et participants au SIAM    L'AMEE sensibilise sur le rôle du pompage solaire    Journée culturelle marocaine en Bulgarie    Bouillon de culture    Remise du Grand prix national de la presse agricole et rurale    Mohamad Salah veut "plus de respect" pour les femmes dans le monde musulman    Vidéo. Le pape lave et embrasse les pieds de douze détenus    La terre a tremblé à Taroudant    Le rapport Mueller n'apporte « aucune preuve » d'ingérence russe, selon le Kremlin    25ème journée de la Botola Maroc Telecom : Avec le derby Wydad-Raja, la course au titre se précise    Marathon international de Rabat : Les migrants sur la ligne de départ    22ème Prix Charjah pour la création arabe : Trois Marocains primés au Caire    Mahjoub Raji: une autre voix s'est éteinte…    Le Maroc aux commandes du réseau MENA de Biosécurité    Algérie: «Le peuple veut qu'ils partent tous!»    Grève des étudiants en médecine. Le spectre d'une année blanche s'éloigne    Oujda : Arrestation d'un Algérien réclamé par les autorités judiciaires de son pays    Mohamed Benabdelkader : La communication contribue au renforcement de la participation à la vie publique    Pôle Nature et vie un voyage en terre connue    Liga : La semaine du titre pour le Barça    Championnats juniors de golf    Communication publique : Le dilemme de la fonction et l'identification de ses rôles    Jiří Oberfalzer : L'Initiative d'autonomie représente une solution durable au Sahara    L'ONU en quête d'unité pour réclamer un cessez-le-feu en Libye    Contribution du Maroc à l'aménagement de la mosquée Al Aqsa et de son environnement    Le Maroc à Abou Dhabi : Ouverture de la 4ème édition dans la capitale émiratie    Tottenham élimine City dans un match d'anthologie    







Merci d'avoir signalé!
Cette image sera automatiquement bloquée après qu'elle soit signalée par plusieurs personnes.





Bank Al-Maghrib, the limitations of an accommodative monetary policy
Publié dans La Nouvelle Tribune le 18 - 03 - 2019

Bank Al-Maghrib's monetary policy has significantly evolved over the past 10 years!
Indeed, in the aftermath of the 2007-2008 financial crisis, Mr Jouahri, its Governor, understood that the traditional role of the institution that he heads up could no longer be limited to containing inflation to avoid a decline in purchasing power.
He therefore introduced a new set of bank refinancing instruments for domestic banks, which, as a result of the crisis, might encounter liquidity shortfalls.
The reason being, was to enable them to continue, in turn, to finance the economy.
At the same time, the Central Bank embarked on a policy of lowering its key interest rate to enable the banking system to offer competitive lending rates for wealth creation.
After four rate cuts, the key rate, known as the ‘base rate,' has stood at 2.25% since 2017.
Ne varietur!
Expectations by businesses and financial institutions were for BAM's Board to maintain an accommodative policy to support economic growth.
They again expressed this wish in September and December 2018, after the Central Bank had left its key interest rate unchanged at 2.25%, which it considered an appropriate level given the country's macroeconomic fundamentals.
In fact, there is widespread belief that, given the current slow rate of GDP growth, BAM could do more to incentivise bank lending with further cuts to its key interest rate.
Adopting an even more accommodative monetary policy would push down lending rates still further and boost the financing of the economy through larger loans.
Indeed, it is clear that non-agricultural economic growth is stabilising at a level that is below its long-term potential. This would appear to be corroborated by the Central Bank's medium-term forecasts, which are hardly optimistic, and which have not seen any noteworthy changes recently. Inflation is forecast at 1.2% for 2019 and at 1.4% over an eight-quarter timeframe, while bank lending, which has stagnated for several months, is showing signs of weakness.
However, with the benefit of hindsight, the transmission of monetary policy into bank lending is easily discernible, despite the fact that low rates do not automatically impact growth in loans to the economy!
For example, in 2012, banking lending grew by about 10% while the key interest rate was only 3.25%. However, after four consecutive rate cuts, each of 25 basis points, loan growth has not picked-up but, on the contrary, has in fact continued to decline!
Bank lending saw a first deceleration phase towards the end of 2015, slowing to below 1% and has since only slightly recovered with growth currently running at between 1.5% and 3%.
On the other hand, it is clear that the transmission system of monetary policy into bank lending rates has functioned correctly. It can be seen from the trend in bank rates that, since 2012, each time the Central Bank has cut its key interest rate, the effect on lending rates has been almost identical.
In fact, when the base rate was cut by 100 basis points, the overall lending rate went from an average of 6.42% to 5.35%, a drop of 107 points, i.e. an entirely consistent move.
Conversely, is would be reasonable to ask why bank lending does not automatically grow when key interest rates and bank lending rates fall?
The answer is certainly economic since a pick-up in bank lending depends on other factors, the main one being business confidence in the private sector. The fact that, since 2012, public spending has contributed significantly to economic recovery by boosting aggregate demand is evidence of this.
Treasury investment has steadily increased and currently accounts for just over 6% of GDP.
As a result, since 2012, outstanding loans to non-financial public enterprises have spontaneously doubled.
Confidence, confidence, confidence …
By comparison, over the same period, outstanding loans to non-financial private enterprises have declined by MAD 20 billion to MAD 346 billion.
At 31 December 2018, outstanding bank loans stood at MAD 866 billion, a 2.7% year-on-year increase, albeit slightly below the 3.1% rate of growth posted a year earlier.
Every loan category listed in the Central Bank's statistics (equipment, treasury, real estate and consumer loans) registered weak growth.
More seriously even, in 2018, average outstanding bank loans stood at only MAD 841 billion, an increase of just 2% year-on-year i.e. the weakest rate of growth over the past 20 years.
One thing is clear, which is that growth in bank lending has remained weak for more than six years.
Year-on-year annual growth in bank loans has fluctuated between a peak of 4.6% in 2012 and a trough of 2.2% in 2014.
Since March 2012, the Central Bank has cut its key interest by 25 basis points on four occasions. As we have shown above, the cuts have been fully passed on to borrowing costs without there being any meaningful impact on bank lending!
As a result, the effectiveness of monetary policy cannot be called into question! The question might also to be ask what would have actually happened to bank lending if BAM's monetary policy had not been so accommodative. Perhaps loan growth might have been even weaker!
And if we look back to 2007, it can be seen that growth in bank lending enjoyed a somewhat euphoric phase which saw the year-on-year annual growth rate exceed 30% when the economy was growing by 6%.
Growth in bank lending was even thought to be excessive as illustrated by the increase in non-performing loans from 4.3% in 2011 to 7.9% in 2016.
As it stands today, the economy has undergone a certain degree of deleveraging as illustrated by the ratio of bank loans to GDP, which has fallen by 10 percentage points from 85% to 75%.
Lastly, if it is confirmed that the current level of bank lending is consistent with non-agricultural growth of between 3% and 3.5%, then loan growth is likely to hit a ceiling at around this level over the next two years.
In the meantime, monetary policy in a low interest rate setting, with no meaningful expansion in bank lending on the horizon, has led to a significant decline in bond yields and has trimmed the investment returns of institutional portfolios, life insurance funds and investment savings, raising a fresh risk of economic deterioration which can only be detrimental to our country's overall growth!
Afifa Dassouli
Original article : https://lnt.ma/bank-al-maghrib-limites-dune-politique-monetaire-accommodante/


Cliquez ici pour lire l'article depuis sa source.